Another overhang piece, stretching out into one direction; the lower part Z-planar, and the overhang conic (outside-cone mode) with an offset to align better with the lower segment:
Overhang Out No 5: 3 Segments: 2x Z-planar & Conic
Perhaps a more realistic approach using the conic part as a “balcony” just for the overhang part sufficiently thick to carry next segment and switching back to Z-planar:
Early tests have shown the thickness of the conic overhang “balcony” depends on the actual length of the in-air overhang, where print speed, part-cooling capacity and extrusion consistency determine the geometrical accuracy. More examples with “balcony” printed with 3-axis FDM printer followed.
Unlike with ordinary Z-planar slicing, it may be suitable to dedicate a particular slicing method and orientation for sub-volumes in order to take advantage of the possibilities like avoiding support structure, particular strength properties or surface quality.
This of course opens a wide-range of possibilities and complexity therefore:
but I think it’s worth it, in particular when a piece is printed more than once like with small series manufacturing / production.
The examples have been produced with various slicers and combined with a new application coordinating the segmenting and dedicated slicing methods, which currently (2021/04) is in development; it also involves a new file-format describing the segmenting and its slicing settings. The segment positioning was done manually as a start, but I expect with more experience and research some cases can be detected automatically.
Sub-volume segmenting is just one approach to take advantage of 5-axis FDM printing, another is continuous slicing along the form.
2021/03/11: starting write-up with basic illustration
I thought to compose a summary of the features of 3 types of 3D printers I currently work on, and its relations to print 90° overhangs – main motivation to go beyond 3-axis 3D printing:
a 5-axis printer PAXhas the same features as a 4-axis printer RTN and 3-axis printer plus it can print at any tilt angle, printing 90° or more overhangs
a 4-axis printer RTN prints conic- or angled sliced models so it can print 90° overhangs in all directions (conic slice) from a central point or single direction (angled slice); the tilt angle is fixed at 45°; Z sliced horizontal layers must be post-processed1) to be printable in acceptable quality but good quality cannot be achived in my opinion
a 3-axis printer by default cannot print 90° overhangs without support (unless it’s tilted 45° as for belt-printer, then only in one direction), but may printconic sliced models with 20-25° cone angle, henceprint 90° overhangs from a central point, and behave partially like a 4-axis printer
a suitable Zrot must be calculated and added to extrusion commands of the G-code, see this example.
Printing an Conic Sliced Overhang
Conic Sliced on 3-axis
A well tuned and well designed part-cooler is prerequisite to print conic-sliced models at cone angle of 20-25°, and currently there is no conic slicer which can properly segment sub-volumes yet (2021/03) to switch from horizontal- and conic-slicing (with two modes of outside/inside cone) where suitable.
and nearly the same with PAX90 (tilt angle 0..90° only) with shorter arm:
A 5-axis Penta Axis (PAX) supports other slice methods than horizontal-, angled- or conic-sliced, but any variable build-orientation, but will make the slicing software very complex to recognize those sub-volumes suitable for advanced slicing methods.
This also means, a 5-axis PAX slicer with proper settings can produce G-code for 5-, 4- and 3-axis 3D printers with combining the horizontal-, angled- and cone slicing for sub-volumes or segments.
Traditionally Horizontal Layers
Slic3r 1.2.9 and Ultimaker Cura 4.8 as comparison:
2021/03/19: some information on use of slicer4rtn (not yet released)
2021/03/09: removed lengthy “Test Protocol” and extended “Gallery” section a bit
2021/03/08: slicer4rtn at 0.2.4 (still unreleased) resulting in better prints, blog-post linked at hackaday
2021/03/05: 95° and 100° overhangs are printable too, more bug-fixes in slicer4rtn
2021/03/04: fixing various bugs in slicer4rtn as disovered printing more complex pieces, supporting prusa-slicer as well aside slic3r, pushing the limits with overhangs
2021/03/02: documenting my findings, a few photos, some early conclusions (not even one day old), conic sliced and tilt sliced.
It has been target of many efforts to print 90° overhangs without support on 3-axis 3D printers as with ordinary Z slicing, each layer requires a support underneath; hence, every overhang then needs a support structure if the model itself doesn’t provide it.
While reflecting on the output of the 4-axis conic sliced models, I thought what if I simply make the cone angle flatter than 45° but 15-25° so the vertical nozzle can print it?
Conic Slices Simulation
A simple overhang model (nr 3) conic sliced at 25° for 0.4mm nozzle, 0.2mm layer height:
Tilted Slices Simulation
The same overhang model (nr 3) tilt sliced at 25° for 0.4mm nozzle, 0.2mm layer height (like with belt printer):
Conic Slices Print Tests
And on the afternoon of March 1st 2021 I ran my G-code for the first time on an ordinary 3-axis printer, a cheap CTC DIY I3 Pro B (Prusa-i3 like), in the attempt to print 90° overhangs, with a conic sliced overhang model:
Wow – it seems to have worked! There were still some issues, like the nozzle without extrusion moved into the print as I forgot map linear motions without extrusion also to conic coordinates as well, and some other minor things.
You may consider this a “backport” of 4-axis slicing procedure back to a 3-axis 3D printing procedure.
Next Day Attempts
The print is still pretty ugly due to the obvious under-extrusion, but the geometry seems to work overall. The overhang on the left-front isn’t evenly, as the outer wall print speed is still too high.
Very clean print so far but the overhang is limited to one direction (see below of overall considerations).
Well,it works, but here are some limitations of using non-planar slicing:
more complex pieces need to be volume decomposed or segmented, e.g. some sub-volume sliced ordinary vertically Z-wise, others conic sliced where needed – this is part of my research on 4-axis and 5-axis printers; and I was hoping some of the findings can be applied to 3-axis 3D printer as well (as this post shows)
the printhead geometry with heatblock sock, part-cooler, LED light they quickly come into way with larger pieces and larger overhangs
this might look minor, but part coolers play significant role for quality prints, so they need to be optimized for non-planar printing
15° works, sufficient space around the nozzle, but on the edge for overhangs, better surface quality
20° works better, layers more stable beneath the overhang
25° works too, but is the limit on my E3D V6 clone, poorer surface quality, but overhang prints better
print quality is sub-optiomal, as the nozzle runs over its own extruded filament and any “flat” surface becomes jittery as it’s not longer flat (toward Z) printed
single direction angled slice like with belt-printer
only one direction overhang possible, but good quality
25° works good, yet, the heatblock comes into the way rather quickly with my sample overhang model
Conic vs Tilted Slices
Issues to Resolve
more beautiful prints
fine tune extrusion rate: the current slicer4rtn does a simple/poor interpolation causing rough top surfaces (under- vs overextrusion)
fine tune outer wall of overhangs, slow them down
support more slicers
Slic3r: supported since slicer4rtn 0.0.1
Prusa Slicer: supported since slicer4rtn 0.1.2 (0.1.1 was broken) but often refuses to slice model, e.g. cube fails in inverted cone space
Trying out an overhang model which extends -Y and Y (as side-ways the part-cooler comes into the way)
There are still inconsistencies with extrusion calculation, but the prints getting cleaner.
4-sided overhang model nr 6 (conic sliced)
Sample print comes soon as I need to redesign my part cooler so I can print this piece.
1-sided long 4mm thick overhang model nr 3 (conic sliced)
Long 40mm overhang, just 4mm thick extending nose . . .
1-sided long 2mm thick overhang model nr 3 (conic sliced)
Long 40mm overhang, just 2mm thin extending nose, let’s push the limits of what’s possible:
OK print so far, better than anticipated, but still a way to improve it. Reprint with a newer version of slicer4rtn (0.2.3):
better surface, no stringing anymore
faster print speed but also more geometric inconsistency like bending up
underside is more uneven but also cleaner than all the previous (pre- 0.2.0 of slicer4rtn)
1-sided short 2mm thick 95° overhang model nr 3 (conic sliced)
Just trying more overhang, let’s see.
Obviously there is more than 95° overhang possible, so let’s try …
1-sided short 2mm thick 100° overhang model nr 3 (conic sliced)
Even steeper overhang, let’s see.
This is truly promising, up to 100° overhangs printable with vertical nozzle as mounted on most 3-axis 3D printers . . .
As of the publication of this blog-post (2021/03) no slicer is available but slicer4rtnwill be made available soon which was released 2021/03/22.
Caution: you need to be an experienced 3D printing enthusiast to proceed, you need to know and realize what you do:
pay close attention of the printhead geometry, such as the nozzle and heatblock, and the part cooler which limits the non-planar printing
depending on the angle, and the direction of extrusion more or less extrusion distortion will occur
--angle=20 is a good start, you may go as low as 15°, and perhaps at max at 30° depending on your nozzle and heatblock, if you aim to print 90° overhangs
--layer-height=0.2 is a good start too, the thinner the layers the better overhangs can be printed
if you have trouble with over- or under-extrusion and your printer otherwise well tuned, then use --erate=f as extrusion-rate tuning, whereas f = 0.5..1.5 or so, if you have to go below or above, something else is wrong.
conic slicing is complex(er), you need to think in new terms:
the slicing procedure requires a conic slicing center
to and from that center overhangs can be printed well
if you have multiple centers, slicer4rtn does not yet support volume segmenting to support multiple centers
slicer4rtn requires manually entered conic slicing center
it requires fine-grained faces so the slicing works well, use --subdivide=5 or higher for simple pieces, e.g. like a cube or low-poly models in generals
Tuning 3-axis 3D Printer
Following changes are recommended:
increase Z axis speed: within the start G-code the line M203 Z.. (replace .. with an actual number) to increase speed of Z-axis
depending on the pitch of your Z-lead screw or threaded rods, you may set it to Z4, Z6, or higher, so the motion speed comes close to X- and Y-axis to improve print quality
if it’s set too high, your stepper motor will block and not move at all
my setup with M6 threaded rod for Z (200 full steps = 1mm):